SOME LUCK by Jane Smiley


This fall, Jane Smiley released Some Luck, the first in a trilogy about a midwestern family, the Langdons. Smiley will ultimately publish three books about the family covering the years 1920-2020, with each chapter dedicated to one year. This first installment – Some Luck – covers the years 1920-1953.

The Langdons are made up of a couple – Walter and Rosanna – and their five children Frank, Joey, Lilian, Henry and Claire. They live on a farm in a rural town in Iowa called Denby. When the book opens, Walter and Rosanna are young parents, and Walter is trying to make a living as a farmer. Some Luck follows the family through the births of the five children, the Depression, World War II, and the 50s, as the kids grow up and start to have their own lives. Frank spends four years in the Army in Europe, where he escapes death many times and sees the horror of the war up close. Joey stays close to home, learning how to farm and introducing his own ideas about seeds, harvests, and machinery. Lillian marries and moves away to Washington DC, opening up the scope of the book beyond Iowa and the war.

In Some Luck, Smiley creates a memorable, diverse family, exploring each member’s inward feelings, disappointments, and hopes.    Just like in life, some years are more momentous (births, deaths, marriages) than others (Fourth of July parties, snowstorms). But each contributes important details and texture about the Langdons and their extended family. Some of the quieter and more domestic passages proved to be the ones I remembered best. I also enjoyed the historical details that gave a glimpse into daily life on a farm 100 years ago.

As it should, with 2/3 still to go, Some Luck feels unfinished. The first book covers the life arc of the family patriarch, so the closure of his story at the end is natural, but there are still many characters with many life stages ahead. The book had a slow start for me (lots of farming) but I gradually found myself getting more and more engrossed. I am looking forward to the release of books 2 and 3 so that I can pick up where I left off with the Langdons. I miss them already.

I listened to Some Luck on audio for the most part, and the performance was just OK for me. The narrator had a very particular way of talking, and it was sort of simplistic, the way you’d talk to a child. That narration was OK for the early chapters about little kids, but it felt out of sync with the more serious parts of the book. I also didn’t like some of the different tones she took on for different characters – I’d rather she had just read all the voices the same. I think I enjoyed the parts of the book that I read more than those I listened to.

Overall – strong start to what promises to be a rewarding trilogy. Tomorrow, I will post my notes from a Q&A I attended with Jane Smiley this fall.

5 Comments

  • December 1, 2014 - 2:05 pm | Permalink

    I listened to this on audio too (while driving around Iowa, which felt right) and also was not a huge fan of the narrator. I actually liked the different voices for dialogue, but I found her narration of the prose and descriptions jarring. I must have gotten used to it, as I found her narration less distracting by the end. Regardless, I’ll be curious if she narrates the other two novels too. I’m too impatient to wait for audio and will be reading the second one soon!

  • December 2, 2014 - 10:25 am | Permalink

    Someone offered this one too me but the idea of it being a trilogy turned me off.

  • Pingback: Everyday I Write the Book2014: Reading Year in Review - Everyday I Write the Book

  • Pingback: Everyday I Write the BookEARLY WARNING by Jane Smiley - Everyday I Write the Book

  • Pingback: Everyday I Write the BookSummer Reading: A Crowdsourced Recommendation List - Everyday I Write the Book

  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *